Repairing & Restoring Clock Cases from the early 20th Century

I got this email so I thought I would do a blog post on this. No pictures for a change – this is a hardcore repair article for those who want to get stuck to a good restoration for pleasure and satisfaction.

“Hi Justin,

I am a clock / watch fan and a bit of an amateur repairer.  I have a number of mechanical clocks around the house that I have breathed life into … most of which have come from lofts and sheds and have been given to me as non-working projects by friends and family.  None are worth much in the material sense but most have some kind of sentimental value, like the mantle clock that was given to my Grandparents on their wedding day and was in turn given to me by my mother.

I bumped-ono your web site when looking for tips on cleaning wooden cases.   I would be very grateful of any tips that you may wish to share on cleaning wooden cases and in particular replenishing the wood – thank you.

Best regards,

John

Colchester”

Repairing and restoring clock cases, specifically those from the early to mid 20th century, can be a minefield. The main problem here is that the veneers used were generally not that high quality. They tend to be thin and dyed. This means if you try to work them they break.

You have to commit to doing the whole case. If you try and refinish part of it you will either create a clock in two colours (one of which you dont want) or you will change the finish on the area you are working on both in terms of texture and colour. If you then apply varinish or laquer to that area it will be very obvious and you will have to start again on a case that was worse than when you started.

Doing the whole case does not necessarily mean stripping off all the old varnish. If the varnish is simply starting to flake then

  1. Use a green scratch rag / sponge to remove the flaking varnish. Apply pressure evenly when you do this so that you dont wear off the varnish in a patches.
  2. Mix 1 part varnish with 2 parts paint thinners. This will create a very thin mixture that you can apply with a sponge. Dont use a brush – its the wrong tool for this and will leave marks and streaks. Apply the varnish thinly so that it is not capable of running / pooling.
  3. Leave 30 minutes between coats and apply 3 coats.
  4. Once dry, buff to a high sheen finish and then use silicone based polish to give it really high gloss UV protective coating.

The above assumes the varnish is just starting to flake and the overall damage isnt that bad.

If the clock has broken sections in its varnish or is excessively worn then you need to strip the old finish away. This is not complicated and simply use regular paint stripper by following the instructions on the tin. All work well and its just a matter of being patient and maybe applying a couple of coats of stripper.

Once thats done give the case a good wash and let it dry thoroughly. You can now apply wood stain to the case before varnishing. When it comes to varnishing you can use a brush but by far the best results will be achieved with the thinning and sponge method described above – lots of layers thinly applied is the rule to follow on this one. If you slap it on thick you will end up with run marks in the varnish, no matter how confident you might be about it applying as you want – just spend the extra time and reap the rewards.

One last thing – your clock might have a toned finish – this being the case avoid the complete strip down option as its hard to replicate.  If thats not an optionthen it can be done by using thinner with a few drops of black paint disolved in it. This allows you to dab on more gradually in the areas to be shaded / toned. The advantage of doing it this way is that you can correct mistakes while you are doing it by simply wiping your dye mixture off with the same thinners you used to dilute it. Also, if you want the darkness to seep into the grain to effect a sort of striped woodgrain effect then you can apply the dyed varnish and then rub it off the relief of the wood. This leaves the stained varnish in relief of the woodgrain. This achieves approximately the same finish as on the originals or these two toned clocks.

One last last thing….invest in a small set of oil paints. Oil paint can be mixed on the palette to get a good colour match and the texture you can apply with a brush makes it easy to simulate wood grain. Give this 48 hours to dry before applying the varnish over the top. Its a great way of filling veneer chips as the paint is thick enough to be used as a filler for most jobs although you will need serious drying time on it.

Im always happy to help people on restorations so just email me if you have any questions or need help on your job.

 

Bavarian Cuckoo Clock Repair

This is an old and rare Bavarian Cuckoo clock Ive just finished. There wasnt really that much to do on it but these old wooden movements need to be carefully handled so it took a bit of time. The results were well worth it. The cuckoo sound is much lighter than on modern clocks and there is not music box. Thats why they sell for so much I imagine!. This one is up for £3000 although I am sure an offer would be considered.

Ive dont peices on wooden movement clocks before as I am a big fan of the genre generally but I have to say this clock is in a league of its own compared to others I have seen. Anyway heres the pictures. I am more than happy to provide more pictures via email for any enthusiasts out there who blog or collect images of these wonderful old clocks.

Bavarian_Cuckoo_Clock_Repair_1

Bavarian_Cuckoo_Clock_Repair_2

Enfield Grammar School Clock Repair

I recently replaced the movement on Enfield Grammar Schools old victorian hall clock. This clock had been build into the panelling so I went out to have a look as seen what needed doing. Mustafa does a great job there keeping everything up to spec and working properly so we agreed a division of labour on this job. I did the mechanics and he arranged to have new roman numerals made up and finished in an appropriate. Hats off to the tech design department who used the remaining metal numerals as a guide for making the missing ones – excellent job and I could not have done better myself quite frankly which is somewhat of an undertatement. You will notice that half the numerals were missing and the wrong colour when we started. At the end we have the clock restored to its former glory which matches the beautiful panelling as if it were new. Its great to get things back to the way they should be!.

On another point I have to say I was particularly impressed with the pupils at this school. Inevitably I became lost in the corridoors and had to seek assistance with directions. I apporoached the first pupil I saw and asked for a bit of help. The student (I wish I had made a note of his name) was one of the most polite and helpful people I have ever met; in or out of shool!.

Here it is before and after.

Enfield_Grammar1

Enfield_Grammar2

David Smith From The Quinpongfangdong province of China. Or India. Probably.

I would love to get feedback from my readers and answer questions and suchlike. I tried it when I launched the blog and while I got some good comments I was besieged with…

“herro good day sir madam, my nam is David Smith. We like blog for good reason. Many good story help me bigger. Very good expert. Many happy. please visit www.PornDe#th_Kill_0908809809808098.co.virus”

I was getting at least five of these a day from people employed, I would guess abroad, to create links to my website in order for google rank their own websites higher.  I had a look at this and thought there must be some way of stopping it. There isnt. Unless you want to force people through a registration system when they want to post on the blog.

Just email me – simple. The alternative is for me to have to log onto the website, go into administration to approve your request, go to your comment, approve it, do that again for everyone who has commented and endlessly go through… computing. I’m not doing it.

Im no big fan of computers to be honest.  I am the first to admit they are an unfortunate necessity with which I could not do without. That doesn’t stop me despising them most of the time. If I had it my way we would communicate by semaphore tower relays and drive clockwork cars wound up at treadmills driven by a slave army of David Smiths and his internet colleagues.

Wall Clock Repair – A Victorian Alarm Clock

 

20170119_003007

You dont see many of these. They are not that rare but far from common. The obvious difference with these is the abscence of a front and back brass plate – it uses wooden stantions to hold the spindles. The spindle holes are brass lined so from a functional perspective its every bit as good as a brass plate solution, however, it takes a lot less engineering to produce. Its a carpenters clock really.

It was in for a full service so it needed stripping right down. If you do one of these its not easy to work out how to get it apart without pulling joints apart!. Don’t do this. Look for one of the pillar feet having what looks like a slipway in it seating. Pull the pillar out via that slipway and the rest is just lego.

If the feet of the clock have dissapeared (a common problem – they fall out and get lost), then you can make new ones. I hand carved these from 12mm dowel and then applied an antiqued finish. You don’t need to do this and its fine just to paint them black but if you dye the wood a medium stain and then smear black paint on by hand you can achieve a very convincing copy of the originals. I give too much away on this blog I suppose but if your maniac enough to start DIY on one of these then good luck to you and I applaud you. I’m all for people having a go and positively encourage it.

Back to the movement.

The only other place I have seen these wooden cage movements is on mid Victorian Bavarian cuckoo clocks with which they share a great deal in common, although this clock has a single slot count-wheel as opposed to a cuckoos normal 12 hour chime count-wheel with 12 slots on the wheel. In the case of this clock that single action count-wheel releases the chiming mechanisn into free fall and lots of alarm bell noise. You stop the clock by simply turning the dial on the front that changes the time the alarm goes off.

Its a clever and simple arrangement. I should have taken a video as that would have explained it much better than my written attempt. Never mind, pictures speak a thousand words. Even if you didn’t really get how it worked from my explanation you can see the clocks simplicity from some of the photos.

I’ve shown it assembled as well as with the cage stripped of cogs for cleaning. Its interesting that the cage arrangement made it easy to put the drive train of cogs in front of the chiming train as opposed to side by side. This is not possible in a two brass plate arrangement where the trains must stand in line like soldiers next to each other facing forward held in place by the plates.

Frankly Im trying to work out why more clocks were not made this way. Its cheaper and more efficient all round.  In terms of complexity the German ones run a chime train with a matching cuckoo so it proves wood is not a material that would hold you back from increasing functionality. It is rather a large movement for a simple clock mind you. And the large cogs don’t require absolute positioning because the teeth of the cogs are large and don’t need such and accurate meshing.  So I suppose it has its limits in terms of physical scale or the ability to scale down.

I still prefer it to a brass mechanical that does the same thing.

Also this is only going to increase in value. You can just tell.

20170116_213912

 

20170115_011421

 

1699 Bracket Clock Verge Escapement Repair

Even after all these years there are some clocks I get in that…

  1. I do immediately.
  2. I should be getting danger money for.

This Bracket clock is one of those. It came into the centre at 3pm, was on my bench by 5pm and finished at 3am. I the customer picked it up at 11am. Thats a 20 hour turnaround. The fact of the matter is that I really care about my reputation for service and this is exaggerated by having a £10k clock on site.  Add to this that old clocks are fragile, impossible to source spares for (you have to manufacture them) and you can see why sleep was not an option.

Ok, so whats a “lever escapement”. Well basically its a crown with two oars hitting it from either side as opposed to a star with an anchor shaped bit hitting it. Its every bit as accurate as an anchor escapement. Its difficult to see why the lever escapement was replaced by the anchor escapement. I suppose the real reason is that the cog on a lever escapement is easier to make as a crown than a star. Its probably as simple as that.  Its a shame really as it looks great when its working.

In terms of maintenance these clocks are just like any other.  Cleaning and lubrication is the same.  This particular clock was running a “bit rough” to give it a technical diagnosis, and with that you have to look for the problem(s). Once I had it apart I could see it was suffering from wear on the escapement paddles. This meant that the teeth of he crown had worn a trench in the paddles where it connected. More of the cog face (the sides as well as the face), was therefore connecting and adding friction. To address this I removed the paddle arm and compound polished out the grooves to a nice flat surface and it was job done. With these clocks you have to work very slowly as accidents CANT happen – there are no spares to rely on. If it was a car it would be a GT40 – the same sort of problems with maintenance.

The next day I fixed two modern kitchen clocks. Thats the great thing – the variety I see.

Anyway feast your eyes on this…..

Sorry about the finger nails. I need them and they get oily!.

20170106_190955

20170106_185522

20170107_104350

c1780 Grandfather clock for sale – £485

Grandfather_Clock_CheapI run my clock repairs from Braintree Antiques Centre and I try and keep the blog on this site separate from the centres because… well, this blog is about clocks and repairs, not about selling clocks. That said I have been asked several times to source a “grandmother clock”. What people mean by this is actually a cottage style grandfather; there is no such thing as a “grandmother clock” but the term is widely used for smaller grandfather clocks. Thats what this clock is – a short grandfather suitable (in height) for a modern house with lower ceilings. So here it is and here is the link to more info on the Braintree Antiques Centre blog.

Possibly the best mantle clock Ive seen…Grasshopper Escapement!

I was called out on a grandfather clock repair and was asked to quote on a service for this one off grasshopper escapement clock.

Normally I would do a long post but this time I have a video that really says it all.

Servicing a clock like this is not as complicated as you might think. All t he components are exposed and after about 5 minutes (most of which was with my mouth open in awe) I was able to see where the adjustment points were and understand the disassembly and assembly operation order.

Those of you who know such things will have noticed the fusee drive and surmised that the pendulum is probably iridium. Normally I am not really one for iridium pendulums – it seems a step too far, however, if the rest of the clock is this finely put together then iridium is sort of.. expected.

 

What a one handed grandfather clock is, and why they were made

I did a quick repair on this grandfather clock. I dont see many one handers so I thought I would do a quick article on them explaining… well, why they only have one hand.!

Before the invention of the pendulum , most clocks only had one hand and were regulated by a thing called a lever escapement which was in turn regulated by a fly wheel or balanced weights going back and forth on a spring. The link below is from the turret clock in Salisbury cathederal which was installed in around 1386 – 300 years before the pendulum clock was invented.

If you want to have a look at the Salisbury clock please follow the wikipedia link below.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Salisbury_Cathedral,_medieval_clock.JPG#/media/File:Salisbury_Cathedral,_medieval_clock.JPG

The point about this weighted regulation on a spring is that it was terribly inaccurate because the oscillation of the weights regulating the clock overall was not particularly consistent.

By about 165o clocks were not expected to run on an accuracy of quarter of an hour a day. On that basis there was no point in trying to add a minute hand as the clocks regulation was not accurate enough to make minute measurement useful.

So, along came Christian Huygens and upset the entire apple cart by attaching a pendulum as the regulating device.

Now, if you dont know, a pendulum will always swing at the same rate on the same arc providing it is not slowed down by friction (which of course it is). The escapement wheel is designed to push the anchor at the top of the pendulum just enough to counter this friction and keep the clock in perpetual motion while its spring or weight is applying force.

Its a brilliant system because its cheap to produce and easy to adjust. The only other option up until the 19th century was to use a platform escapement which to all intents and purposes is what you will find in a mechanical watch. These wear out, can only be adjusted withing certain limits, and they are fragile. All this meant that a reasonably priced accurate clock made between 1658 and around 1960 uses a pendulum for regulation.

The problem with the “new fangled” pendulum clock in the first few years of its production is that it was so accurate it was possible to add an accurate minute hand. This might seem like a great improvement but actually the largely illiterate population didn’t understand how to read two hands. They were used to just looking at a clock face with one hand and reading what time it was to the nearest quarter of an hour. Imagine if we lived in a world where everything timed, e.g. meetings, events, scheduled tasks, was only planned to the nearest quarter of an hour!.

So from 1658 to about 1700 the majority of clock were produced with just the one hand. Two handed clocks did appear during this period but the majority were single handed. By 1700 two handed clocks were being sold BUT they still had the one handed markings. If you see a grandfather clock that has both minute markers on the outer chapter ring AND quarter hour markers on the inner ring then its was almost certainly made between 1690 and 1720 although some makers persisted with dual marked faces up until 1740.

Note also the half hour markers which, again, made it through to the two handed version but were marked for the second hand and 7.5 minutes, 22.5, 37.5 and 52.5 minutes.

An example of a clock head (my own John Mason London Clock) below. Note that the chapter ring appears to be steel – it is not, it is a slivered brass chapter ring produced by a silvering process that predates any kind of electroplating by a couple of hundred years. The black letters are filled with wax – if you doubt the autheniticity of a 1700 clock check to see if the roman numerals have been carved in and then filled with a black wax which should be cracking a bit and possibly the odd flake missing.

john_mason_london_clock

 

The clock below is a John Taylor clock from about 1680 -1700 and as you can see it just has the single hand and the inner chapter ring marks, which at first glance look like minute markers for a second hand, but are of course quarter hour markers for this single handed clock.

Incidentally the other thing that dates this clock to the period is the lack of an arch over the dial. These were common after 1700 so along with the one handed format we can take a good guess (without looking up things!) that this clock was produced within the dates previously mentioned.

img_20161205_171030

Heres a picture of the whole clock.

img_20161205_171008

Comitti Clock Repair

I have nothing but praise for this clock. I dont get to work on many well engineered modern clocks as they last at least 50 years before anything needs replacing. On this occasion the clock had been “repaired” by somebody else and they had not mounted the mainspring in the barrel correctly. Therefore, when the ratchet gave out on the winding spindle the tension reduced to zero and the end of the spring failed to catch its loop in the barrel. The effect of this was the spring slipping back after a couple of winds i.e. no power.

Basicly this meant taking the whole clock completely to bits which is a long and slow job. Having said this the design of this clock made the job particularly straight forward. It was the little quality touches such as the mounting of the chime bars that made a huge difference.

If your thinking of buying a new or second hand clock then have a look at a Comitti as they seem to be very well engineered. Other modern clocks I work on often have a 3rd party movement and are all brass and boasting whereas these Comitti clocks are the real deal – they make the whole thing (very well).

Expect the pay low thousands but also expect to get your moneys-worth. Good clocks.

Heres a picture of its naked fabulousness!

comitti_clock_repair