What jewels are in movements

Far be it from me to educate anyone but this is worth knowing from a quality perception angle. Note that I say “perception”. There are average and good and god like types. To get a handle on this to any level where you can appreciate what “8 Jewells” means to price, for instance. So whats going on with jewels…

It is I am sorry to tell you its to do with mollecular mechanics. I will dumb it down. Each time the torque vector in any rotational system some level of inertial blah blah blah.. Hmmmm

Metals are made from crystals. Surprise. Like the ones you buy for jewellery. They are not pure and see through like diamonds because all the atoms in, say a ruby, are exactly stacked like eggs in a pallet of eggs. Every single egg is exactly where is should be so you can stick a this stick right through the pallete through the regular straignt gaps. As an aside, thats how light gets through crystal fundementally. Anyway metal is also like stacked eggs but imagine the pallete of eggs in the back of a lorry. You would be lucky to get a long long thin stick,in one go, through back doors of the lorry, to the back of the cab.

So rubys are like massive pallets of eggs, and metals are lots of slightly misaligned pallete of eggs firmly held together. Set that aside.

Brass is lots of palletes of normal eggs, slightly misalligned, MIXED IN with a pallets of ostritch eggs. And this is where is gets comlicated. If you mix up normal eggs and ostritch eggs the brass they produce has a putty like quality in the brass they form. Its still what you or I would regards as hard but when you rub it with anything but plastic or wood, at a molecular level youve spread the butter. And some of it sticks to the knife you were using as well.

So think about that if you have 3 materials to work with and you have to design a stick that goes into a hole and turns round without wearing the hole bigger as it goes round. Lets look at the options.

  1. A brass pole in a brass hole. Butter everywhere, lasts about 10 minutes which is all it takes to make the damn thing because brass is so easy to work.
  2. Steel pole in steel hole. Ok, massive mollecular problem. In theory its good. You have all you millions of normal egg crates slighly offset but bassically strong and structurally organised. They are formed into a tubular pole. It appears perfectly smooth. Its ISNT, its violently abrasive because you cant make a molecularly smooth curve from straight line geometric metal grains (egg crates). Compounding this is he fact the the hole has exactly the same problem at its surface. Its like molecular sandpaper being rotationaly rubbed together. Oil mitigates the effect but it still happens progressively not matter what. Like us, clocks die from the first tick. So dont waste time.
  3. A steel pole in brass hole. Have you ever tried to sandpaler a lemon tart?. It doesnt work. The sandpaper gums up and slides over the tart. This is the anwer for most clocks. Thats why you have steel pinions and brass holes (bushes). Obviously you keep it to a minimum with oil but when you see a deformed pinion and bush you see that the wear is bodiced as if there is some fluidity in the wear which is exactly what it is. Glass is fluid, church windows hundreds of years old are apparently thicker at the bottom as the have sagged over the centuries. Or more probably the cast the thinner glass where it would add less aggregated weight and was less likely to require toughness. Or god ordained it. Hard to know, but with pinions its proven.
  4. Steel in jewels. Ok so we have a new egg. The quails egg. Its tightly packed pallets pefectly alligned and as such, any step based curve in its edge is a finer and less destructive abrasive. The steel, when manufactred with super small pallets can form material curved edges with small steps and therefore a lower abrasion rating. Not perfect but not bad at all if the holy grail is zero wear (Ive invented one – later). But here is the thing. The real culprit here is engergy transfer. This is the multiplier and analogous to the size of the stick and the hole. You see if your stick is a broomstick and our hole… a broomstick hole. Then the size of all that add all sorts of extra drag. You are drag with you weak humanoid puny muscles, the broomstick isnt carbon fibre is it, and you didnt even check what the ground was like. Hopeless. Gravity as well. And its probably dark and you didnt even think about a torch. So, if we scale down to a clock it becomes simpler. Our puny muscles are a nice known power spring, our friction is our molecular wear and our pole and hole is our pinion and bush. If its a gradfather clock then the steel and brass works. Its easy to work with, the steel can be very finely lathed and the bushes accurately drilled. Its a common sense manufaturing method to an end, which is a 50 year run with a 100 year overhaul. I have no idea if those timescales were calculated but thats the case. Very human terms if you think about it – for life and as far as can be imagined within reason. And now we have iphones. I digress, so on top of the fact we have good machining for bushes (jewels can be drilled very accurately a a few hairs diameter) we also have scale. If you go watches then the components dont have any appreciable gravitational coefficient to allow for so providing you have oil, jewel bushes and really accurate manufacture you can talk to clock god.

So thats the mechanics of jewels. If your watch is a mechanical without jewels read the above again and go shopping. If you see a mantle clock with a jewelled movement then buy it because it looks nice. By the time it wears out you will be dead and some relative will have to track down clock Einstien for an achaelological repair. I have one. I love it but thats beside the point. Buy something else where the jewels matter. The only clock we did that was longcase was a barometric monitoring control clock with an irridium pendulum. It was 5ft high with an irridium pendulum and had ruby bushes. Unbelievable. Accurate to within 3 seconds a month and we fixed it. To 3 seconds a month. The absolutely most terriffying job we have ever done but a country mile. The bloke had a lift in his house. His wife answered the door and I waited in the hall. This glass tube pod with lights in decended from a hidden opening in the ceiling. All it was missing was cryogenic smoke. We dont charge enough.

A repairers view on running antique clocks

So….a tricky subject because what you will read here may ruin you current clock routine.

Its the history of the clock that really appeals to me and most others who collect or have a single holy grail clock. I am in the middle with a trinity. In ascending order, Carriage, Grandfather, Black forest double fusee cathederal style table top wooden cage cuckoo (for short). I now only run these in a particular erratic cycle which I will explain. Its about dignity, specifically the dignity of the clock. Like its a person. Do you demand constant service from your mother or your friend or the local shaman viking church leader?. No. You go to the temple to worship, not crack a whip. If you crack the whip your friend (or shaman prophet) will tire of you. They will be wear and tear on the relationship and by the time you have finsihed with them you will have changed them. This metaphor works for me perfectly but Ill spell it out for muggles.

If you run a clock as a daily it definitely means servicing it. If you fix it only when it stops then its probably going to come out of clock hospital with a replacement hip and assorted prostetics. Every engineering change on a service is a reductive or additive process. The clock changes each time you service it. Your killing the value both commercially and historically. And its your clock. You are doing that to yourself. You dont have to be a life coach to see the problem here.

My carriage clock is an inherited item that belonged to a prolific member of the family tree. I love the clock because its really good quality and was really expensive when first bought. For what it is, there are few better. Its conservative and beautiful, and opulent in its engineering. After a recent service and polish of the movement it looks particularly nice. Its now has an almost gold movement clearly visible through an even patina case. I left the case unpolished but clean and dry to effect the contrast to the gold of the movement. The clock is in the best looking and functioning condition it WILL EVER BE!. And thats the point. I know for a fact that if I run the clock as a daily then the bits that wear will need major replacement probably by my family later this century. The pinions for instance. Its all very well rebushing but think about the aggregated wear on the pinons that go into the bushes. As the pressure within the bush changes with wear pattern you get high and low areas wich leads to radial striation. Basically the pinon ends up scored and bodiced. That process happens…. when you run the clock and only when you run the clock. A bit every time. Tick tock ££££ la la la la destruction of what you love as well as the historical record. You see, once a pinion wears to that level it will have to be replaced. Its like having to graft new fingers onto michealangelos David because the tourists like shaking his hand as they pass (they dont). Its not the same afterwards.

The cherry on this cake of doom is if you find pinion wear in one place the rest of the clock is probably pretty rough as well in my experience. Almost always. It gets even more alarming when you condiser the…alarm, specifically the chiming mechanisms. So, think about this. It is assumed by many that the finesse of friction mechanics in the pinions is reflected throughout the rest of the moving parts on of clocks. This is rarely the case. Chiming hammer mechanical assemblies are made to deliver power to counter torque resistance, not for low friction. The cost of that is fast and progressive wear patterns in areas like hammer levers, activation cams and selectors. Pretty much everything outside the plates, and there is a lot outside the plates. The tradition is not to oil these things, or it gets missed so the wear is always there. Once those components fail you are into costs for custom parts production. The last worm I will put in your brain is that if you bring me a brand new clock that you have run for 1 day with a chiming system, Im pretty sure I could show you the physical wear. This is because when you drag steel or brass over polished brass, it scuffs (wears). You can see one days wear and after a month its obvious if you look. Sorry. Im saving clocks so its gloves off.

Also consider the change in repair services and how that effected the design of your clock. The fact of it is that the reason less attention was paid to the friction mechanics outside the timing gears is that it was easy to get parts replaced. There were tons of people doing clocks when the antique ones were not antiques. The clock is designed for remedial service infrstructure which no longer exists. No parts, few skills, everything is a special in one way or another. Try getting a new head gasket for your ford fiesta in 100 years.

Heres the strange thing. If you own a vintage porche or ferrari you are very aware that its costing you a lot to use it and you limit your use as the average owner (I imagine). Its second nature to rest the asset in that scenario but oddly, not with clocks. I have found with my clocks that running them and knowingly making them less forever, is a guilty pleasure. Everyone needs sugar in their diet, so to speak. I really enjoy running my carriage clock and I often do. Every few months, usually around some event or visit, I crank up the grandfather and the carriage clock. Hearing and marvelling at them every now and again is genuinely much better, as an experience, than the grafication you get from daily use. Either way you still get the gollumn “my precious” moments so you may as well tell your clock that, for its years of faithful temporal slavery, you are giving it a holiday entitelment. Possibly even a nose job and kidney transplant.

At any rate, thats the case for not running your clocks. Get them done properly and then own them as valued assets not daily fodder. Actually, there is one more thing. A lot of my customers are anxious about their clocks, specifically the running state and condition. All of them run their clocks daily. I was the same and regarded the running as some sort of responsibilty in many ways. This, for me, is not a thing anymore and I think I may very well feel like a weight has been lifted. You should definitely try it. That said dont overdo it. When customers collect their clocks its incredibly common for them to comment on how the abscence has been conspicuous and unsettling, specially grandfather clocks. I fear I may be metaphorically telling you to send you children to boarding school. “clocks should be seen and not heard blah blah”.

Whatever. Do what you want. We have had loads of really good Victorian cuckoo clocks in recently. Awesome machines – I will post about it at some point.

What? You are not convinced. Well sir, I shall point you in the direction of phonons. Ive just learned about these. A phonon is essentailly the quantization or unitary measure of a molecular vibration. Like a little packet of energy. Imagine your clocks atoms. They are all nice and neat and tightly bonded in a crystaline lattice and fantastically safe. But….then the clock ticks. Billions of phonons flood the escapement wheel. Chaos. Atoms flying everywehere. Issac newtons quantum ghost forces the maelstrom of phonons into a frenzy of energy conservation as the phonons, unable to escape the escapement, ricochet and agitate emitting hot infra red particles like anti aircraft fire. Squillions of clock atoms distort in the sacred crystaline matrix which has been forever changed. Then the clock chimes. Phononic Clockageddon. I need not go on.

I cant be bothered to spell check this. It took ages.

The accuracy of cuckoo clocks.

I am often contacted by people who are having the problem of a cuckoo clock either gaining or losing time. The subtext of the question is usually “what the f am I doing wrong – surely the bloody thing tells the time as well as entertains”.

Well the answer is yes. In fact, a recently serviced, or even a not so recently serviced cuckoo clock, can be accurate to within the same tolerances as say, a medium priced mechanical clock. A minute or three out per week but easily adjusted for when you wind the clock up daily. One day cuckoo clocks are more accurate than most 30 hour mechanical wall clocks for instance. There are a few reasons for this.

Firstly the time gearing is well seated with thick pinions. They have a longer functional lifespan so the clock therefore remains in the same frictional dynamic for a stretched out period. About 25 years on a 20th century clock with servicing when performance starts to degrade. Generally that’s anything from 3 pet hair exposed years to a clean pollen free and clean room level of environment.

Secondly, the pendulum is made out of wood. Wood doesn’t stretch over time as metal does. It’s treated wood so it stays in shape and simply hardens over decades. Also wood isn’t known for its expansion under heat and the pendulum is so short it would need to expand like a balloon for it to make any real difference. Lastly the centre of gravity is simpler because the wooden pendulum rod, providing its the length the movement was designed for, is light. The bit that carries the momentum and mass is the wooden leaf shaped (normally) pendulum bob.

The last reason cuckoo clocks can be quite accurate is because they are so simple to adjust in terms of running fast or slow (regulating a clock). You just slide the leaf up and down until you work out exactly where the sweet spot is.

This is the point where you can’t quite work out if the clock is running a minute fast or a minute slow over one day. You can put up with a minute a day adjusted for. Fiddling could achieve watch level accuracy. Sometimes.

Regulation on an 8 day clock takes longer. It’s the same method but with the time difference check weekly when you pull the weights up. You could do it daily but let the pendulum settle into it’s normal arc of swing before starting the timer.

Anyway when you pull the weights up most people knock the pendulum, stop the clock and have to reset the time anyway. It’s just what happens. I do it all the time on test jobs which can be annoying. Just take it easy, like I don’t enough, when you pull the chain. Don’t try and do a Tarzan on it like the grandkids / nephews.

Lastly, because this blog is about insight and helping people ill tell you the method you use to quickly and accurately regulate any pendulum based clock. It’s called “the rule of dividing halves”. Google it.

Just remember that to use the rule, you have to know that moving the leaf up the wooden shift speeds up the swing and therefore the speed of the clock. Just remember “up,faster” and because they are superlative in nature you will remember.

Obviously the opposite applies for moving the leaf down. To be fair, if you didn’t already realise that I genuinely congratulate you on finishing this article.

Cuckoo clock repairs. How can this even be interesting to anyone.

Next time I’ll explain how cosmology works in relation to quantum physics and prove, on the basis of probability, the inevitability of what you mortals call God. Nobel prize stuff. Tune in.

Cuckoo clock repairs – common problems & fixes

Bavarian_Cuckoo_Clock_Front

I repair a lot of cuckoo clocks. Most repairers wont do them as…well you certainly work for the money and every clock is unique and handmade in some way. In short they are considered a pain in the back side and theres other easier work to persue. Not for me though because I really quite enjoy them. Its as if somebody has spliced train set DNA with an alarm clocks while drunk. Some of the key switches inside the clock that make things happen are simply hand bent wire. Amazingly this architecture keeps running fine and consequently a properly set up cuckoo will be reliable, accurate and about the same to service and run as a more ordinary clock.

Its taken me some considerable effort and investment to honour my “I fix ANY clock” promise on these but I am there now with a full set of spares and all the diagnostic equipment required.

I do a fair amount of Reglula clocks as well as Hubert Herr which I can recommend (the best built and most reliable) and I can cover all the popular makes if yours is not a Hubert.

So what are the common problems….

  1. Dirt. These clocks collect dirt like you wouldn’t believe. To keep a clock clean it needs to be enclosed so the dust doesnt get it. Bearing in mind cuckoo clocks are designed to open and shut a door a hundred or so times a day its hardly surplussing they collect dirt so quickly. Cleaning the movement requires great care and the right cleaning fluids because the clocks often contain plastic components which melt in solvents or degrade in aggressive household cleaning products that are now formulated to remove everything – Cillit Bang doesnt work – “Bang and the clock is gone” springs to mind.
  2. Component seizure. This happens a lot specially around the weight arbors. Reseting requires the clock to be stripped down.
  3. Out of sync automaters. Basicly the chain linkage slips and your little dancers or cuckoo come out at the wrong time or only get halfway through their dance before just stopping. Cuckoos sing the wrong amount of notes and pop out all over the place – all this can get quite comical and its not ucommon for me to spend the first 10 minutes of fix time just laughing at what the owners have put up with before taking the plunge and sending it to me.
  4.  Broken hands and front of face components. These are generally glued on or held with a friction fit so they often fall off or work loose over time. All can be replaced with contemporary spare parts however if you want bone or colour matched hands it takes a bit longer to source parts.

I do repair all cuckoo clocks and am currently restoring an 1860 black forest table top clock in the Dresden style (a stunning clock and its ALL MINE!). Most of the clocks I get in are mid to late 20th century units but its a varied field and cuckoo clocks have been made in volume since about 1800 so its quite a job covering them all (but I do!).

Half the clocks are sent to me in the post which is fine. As long as you use a bigger box than you need with plenty of packaging they travel ok. I send them back set up correctly with all the chains and loose fixings tied into place with cable ties so you can just unbox it and stick it on the wall ready to go – I include written instructions.

Im always happy to exchange emails before quoting etc and I take calls in the day if you want to ring. Some people just work out Im good at these and stick them in a box to send me without any  warning – thats fine too but don’t forget to put a note it with your address and some brief notes on what is wrong and what you want done.

The only thing I dont do on cuckoos are replacing bird skin bellows material (chicken skin was used in the bellows of early clocks) but if you want that I know a man who can!. Even on my expensive Dresden clock Ive just gone with modern replacements – they are consumable items and trying to preserve them through services is just putting off the inevitable and adds rediculous money to repairs bills.  Cuckoo clocks should be fun, not expensive or high maintenance.

In terms of costs its no more expensive to get a cuckoo fixed by me than it is to get a mid range mantel clock fixed so dont worry about it being prohibitive. £60 for an over the counter while you wait fix (where possible) or up to a max of £400 plus parts for a top end modern Bavarian cuckoo that will have typically cost £1500 new.

Any questions…just give me a ring for some help or a chat 07462 269529.